Anyone got hard rejected for their plugin?… What should I do next?

I found a cool micro SaaS called PoopUp that lets you show popups on any website. It got me thinking - I could build a WordPress plugin to do the same and sell it on CodeCanyon. I whipped it up in a few days, submitted it, but they gave it a thumbs down (hard rejection means no second chances there).

So, I’m stuck with this plugin. I’m wondering if I should just make it free and publicly available on WordPress.org.

Here’s a demo in case you’re curious: https://app.instawp.io/launch?t=-wp-poopup-demo&d=v2

The biggest issue for me is the name inside the plugin… it’s not really appealing for clients. I think if you change the name and do a bit of advertising, it could be a really cool plugin. You could also distribute it on your own.

Fair point. I’ll work on rebranding it.

Quick question though: how much would you be willing to pay for this plugin? I’m just trying to figure out the best price.

It depends on a couple of things. First, will you keep adding new features, or is this the final version? And, are you planning to offer a lifetime license or an annual one? A good idea might be to start with a lifetime deal at a good price for the first month, so you can build up your name on this forum. Maybe even offer a free version on the Wordpress plugin hub to get traction. After that, you can switch to a yearly license. As for pricing, you might want to ask others here since I’m not an expert, but personally, I wouldn’t pay more than €80 (with taxes, that’s about €100). But hey, I’m a small web agency, so I really watch my budget haha!

One more thing: I tested the plugin, and right now, it doesn’t do a whole lot. You might want to add more features, like links in the popups, a close button in the top right, better animations to look more like real notifications, settings for each popup, and maybe a trigger based on cookies so people don’t keep seeing the same popup every time they visit the site.

I don’t want to sound harsh, but this forum is kind of dead for selling plugins. There’s barely any traffic. Don’t feel bad about the rejection.

I’m interested in collaborating with you. Let’s talk!